We will meet
early in the semester to determine the day and time of our regular meetings,
and try to find a time that works for everyone. We usually meet on Mondays,
but that is subject to change so as not to conflict with other humanities
courses. The preferred time would be 3:30-5:30.
Feel free to
contact me with any questions you may have, either before or after you
register, at 661-7970 or at the email address below.
Syllabus for 2012
Text:
Gregory Pence, Classic Cases in Medical Ethics, Sixth
Edition (2010)
Assignments:
Before each
session, email me three or four discussion points: concepts, passages, or
arguments you do not fully understand, points of disagreement with the
author, questions you would pose for discussion, etc. If there are multiple
readings, there should be at least one item per reading. Send these to me
by 1:00 on class day at
chackler@uams.edu
Session 1:
Introduction to course
1/30
Session 2:
Concepts and Theories of Ethics
2/6 Rachels,
Elements of Moral Philosophy, Chapters 1, 7-9 (handout)
Session 3: First
Tuesday Ethics Discussion, Whit Hall, MD
2/7
(Tue. 3pm)Third-floor Classroom, ACH
Session 4:
Refusal of Treatment and Suicide
2/13
Pence, Chapters 1-2
Chen, Making your wishes known at the end of
life. New York Times, April 15, 2010
Chen, Why doctors can’t predict how long a
patient will live. New York Times, January 19, 2012
EPERC Fast Fact and Concept #10 and #84 (tube
feeding)
Session 5:
Physician-assisted Dying
2/20 (No
meeting: Presidents Day Holiday)
Pence, Chapter 3
Session 6: Comas,
Consciousness, and Futility
2/27
Lindell, Sensitive topic of futile medical care faces long road in
legislature. statesman.com, March 8, 2011
AMA Code of Ethics: Medical futility in
end-of-life care
University Hospital Policy on Redirection of
Care
Kolata, Murky path in deciding on care at the
end. New York Times, February 23, 2010
Harrell, A flicker of consciousness. Time,
November 28, 2010
Ropper, Cogito ergo sum by MRI. N
Engl J Med. February 3, 2010
Cruise, Bedside detection of awareness in the
vegetative state: a cohort study (abstract). The Lancet, December 17,
2011
Overgaard, Measurements of consciousness in
the vegetative state. The Lancet, December 17, 2011
Session 7:
Physician-assisted Dying, Palliative Care and Hospice
3/05
Guest: Dr. Reed Thompson
Meier, Lifesaving devices can cause havoc at
life’s end. New York Times, May 13, 2010
American Medical News, Turning off heart
devices….
Healy, The promise and pitfalls of palliative
care. Los Angeles Times, October 24, 2011
Hartocollis, Hard choice for a comfortable
death: sedation. New York Times, December 27, 2009
VA National Ethics Committee Report, The
ethics of palliative sedation (excerpt). March 2006
Kahn, Occupational hazard: playing the fool.
New York Times, June 7, 2010
Session 8:
Definition of Death and Organ Donation
3/12 Guests:
Dr. Drew Toler, Family Services Mgr., ARORA
Dr. Jerril Green, ACH Critical Care
Pence, Chapter 11, Allocation of artificial and
transplantable organs.
Sanghavi, When does death start? New York
Times Magazine, December 20, 2009.
Perspective: Organ donation after cardiac
death (3 short articles). The New England Journal of Medicine, August
14, 2008.
3/19
Match Week Break
Session 9:
Research Ethics and IRBs
3/26
Pence , Chapter 9, Research on human subjects
Pence, Chapter 10, Surgeon’s desire for fame
Emmanuel, Wendler, and Grady, What makes
clinical research ethical? JAMA, May 2000
Session 10:Arkansas Medical Society Distinguished Lecturer: Toby
Schonfeld, Emory University. Attend either one of the following:
4/03(Tue.)
First Tuesday Ethics Discussion, ACH 3rd Floor Classroom
4/04
(Wed.)
OB/GYN Grand Rounds, Shorey 5/25, 7am
Session 11: Health
System Reform
4/09
Pence, Chapter 16
Pevtzow, Aging out of health care?
Chicagotribune.com, November 30, 2011
Kolata, Surgery rate late in life. New York
Times, October 5, 2011
Session 12: Issues
in Genetics
4/16
Pence, Chapter 14, Testing for Genetic
Disease
Hackler, Extending the Life Span. HEC Forum,
2004.